# ISS-ASTRO-2026-001 — Sky Viewer reports the ISS above the horizon while Earth blocks the line of sight

## 1 Scope

Confirmed implementation defect in Quizzman Astro, opened on 9 November 2026. [QP-ASTRO-002](/papers/QP-ASTRO-002/en/) provides the reference model for local horizontal coordinates. This dossier records the implementation discrepancy and acceptance criteria.

## 2 Reproduction

Call `GET /viewer/sky` at UTC JD `2461247.91084145` (26 July 2026, 09:51:36.7 UTC), with `lat=-57.9853756307`, `lon=-164.0726625097`, `elevation=0`, `refraction=none`, and `magLimit=0`. This synthetic case uses the NORAD 25544 TLE at its epoch. The original observation's site and time remain unknown.

| Field | Captured origin | SGP4/WGS84 reference |
| --- | ---: | ---: |
| Slant range | 11,518.000 km | 11,518.000 km |
| Geometric elevation | +2.100° | −59.874° |
| Azimuth east of north | 86.637° | 177.706° |
| Above horizon | Yes | No |

The reference uses SGP4 2.25, WGS84, and UTC as an approximation of UT1. The reproduction script pins the TLE, inputs, and origin capture. [Download the reproduction script](/papers/QP-ASTRO-002/issues/ISS-ASTRO-2026-001-check.py).

## 3 Findings

1. **High — Incorrect elevation and azimuth.** Range in `iss_at` uses the satellite-minus-observer vector. The Alt/Az branch treats a GMST-rotated geocentric direction as inertial right ascension and applies sidereal rotation again. [Astro source at 8d7dbb2](https://github.com/the-quizzman/Quizzman-Astro/blob/8d7dbb2/rust/astro-core/src/satellite.rs#L124).
2. **High — TLE age is unchecked.** A 9 November 2026 request still returned a 26 July 2026 epoch, almost 106 days away, without a stale-data flag. The comparison in Section 2 runs at the TLE epoch and isolates the geometry defect from propagation age.
3. **Medium — Viewer carries stale ISS samples forward.** Slim batches omit the ISS. The viewer retains the prior sample and can update elevation while preserving the old range. [Viewer source at 8d7dbb2](https://github.com/the-quizzman/Quizzman-Astro/blob/8d7dbb2/docs/js/sky-viewer.js#L641).

## 4 Acceptance criteria

- Derive elevation, azimuth, and range from one line-of-sight vector in a consistent frame. Compare zenith, near-horizon, Earth-blocked, eastward, and westward cases against an independent reference. [CelesTrak coordinate reference](https://celestrak.org/columns/v02n02/).
- Select a TLE appropriate to the request time. Report stale or unavailable data outside the validated interval. Cover fresh, stale, missing, and malformed elements.
- Preserve sample time and observer coordinates with all displayed ISS fields in both static and playback modes. Distinguish the horizon flag from naked-eye visibility.

## 5 Resolution Status

This issue dossier is formally **Resolved & Closed** per Issue Fix Report [QPS-IFR-ASTRO-2026-001](/reports/QPS-IFR-ASTRO-2026-001/en/) published on 10 November 2026:
- **ISS-01 (Patched):** Complete topocentric ENU horizon transformation implemented on the WGS84 ellipsoid in `satellite.rs`.
- **ISS-02 (Patched):** 14-day TLE staleness control added, returning `is_stale: false` and `status: "valid"` with updated November 2026 orbital elements.
- **ISS-03 (Patched):** Sky Viewer continuously synchronizes ISS data during playback without retaining stale samples.
- **Verification:** 65/65 unit tests pass (100%), elevation residual against SGP4/WGS84 benchmark < 0.000001°, production service verified and operational.
